en.news

Leo XIV Unlikely to Overturn 'Traditionis Custodes' – U.S. Bishop

Bishop Michael Martin of Charlotte, North Carolina, has defended his decisions to restrict the celebration of the Traditional Latin Mass to only one location and to prohibit the use any tools for kneeling at Communion.

In an interview with AmericaMagazine.org on 26 March, he began with a thinly veiled dismissal of Catholics attached to the Roman rite: "I don't want to say that they're some sort of lunatic fringe. They're not. These are people who feel strongly about the liturgy, and there's goodness and holiness in that."

Leo XIV Would Not Change what Francis Has Done

Monsignor Martin referred to his responsibility as a bishop to maintain fidelity to the Church’s "norms". He framed his cruel decisions, especially those relating to the Traditional Latin Mass, as an act of obedience: "All I did was implement Traditionis Custodes in the Diocese of Charlotte."

The bishop rejected the idea of extending the existing Masses indefinitely without a clear pastoral plan to end them: "If we need more time, then show me what you're going to do in the next two years so that things will change."

The bishop found that the rationale of Catholics was different: "It was simply, 'We want to celebrate the liturgy this way'."

According to Monsignor Martin, Catholics were hoping that a future pope would reverse the decision. "There were those who were saying, 'Why don't you just wait?'"

But: "I thought the chances of Pope Leo XIV changing what Pope Francis had done were relatively slim."

Kneeling for Communion Has "No Place" in Novus Ordo

Regarding kneeling for Holy Communion, Bishop Martin admitted that his concern was "not reverence", but consistency with liturgical "norms".

He realised that Masses in the Roman rite had reintroduced kneeling for Communion into the Novus Ordo, saying: "That's not what the norm calls for."

And: "Common gestures are part of the norms, and in the United States, the norm for receiving Communion is standing", he claimed, without quoting anything.

Click on the video sequence below to get a glimpse his voice and intonation.

#newsFeapwqpovo

00:59
51K
john333

His generation thought clericalism was rampant in pre Vatican II .To bring down our lord to a level of a jolly good fallow instead a Lion of tribe of Juda is messing with fire.

Wilma Lopez shares this

Bishop of Charlotte addresses Latin Mass controversy

1286
tbswv

Care to provide us the reason why? Personal opinions do not apply here.

Sally Dorman shares this

Bishop Michael Martin says he didn’t expect Leo to defend the Traditional Latin Mass and is moving to eliminate its influence, including removing altar rails and limiting the old Mass in Charlotte.

1205
Opera 369

He should do Charlotte a big favor, after 'removing altar rails' etc., he should ..remove himself! Maybe go to the "end of the earth" (where his hero Bergoglio came from) and form a band of novus "pachapapas".. 🥳

Mike the Pike

Who is "norm"? Is that a new pope? 😂

Mike the Pike

Suppress the expression of faith. Hey bishop, are you also planning to shut down public masses again like during 2020?